Risk Management: The Role of Underwriters in Financial Markets

By Lily Hackett Jan 4, 2024

Dive into the crucial role of underwriters in various financial sectors including mortgages, insurance, loans, and investments.

In the world of finance, underwriters hold an indispensable role as evaluators and assumers of risk. These professionals, usually belonging to a larger financial organization, analyze the risk posed by insurance, mortgages, loans, or investments and determine whether to take the associated risk in exchange for a commission, premium, spread, or interest.

These risk managers must assess the probability of a borrower meeting their loan repayment obligations alongside the availability of sufficient collateral in the event of a default. Insurance underwriters, for instance, gauge a policyholder's health among other factors, spreading the possible risk across as many individuals as practical.

In the mortgage industry, equity markets, insurance sector, and common types of debt securities trading, these underwriters perform a crucial task. The individual leading this process is often referred to as a lead underwriter or a book runner.

In present-day markets, underwriters perform a wide array of roles depending on the industry. They assess risks relative to a transaction or business decision – risk being the likelihood that the actual profits from an outcome or investment will differ from the expected return.

It is for this reason that investors rely on underwriters. They aid in determining if a business risk merits the investment. Some underwriters also engage in sales activities, such as buying the entire issue in an initial public offering (IPO) and selling it to investors.

The key role of a common underwriter – to approve applications based on a combination of the applicant’s income, credit history, debt ratios, and overall savings – gained prominence in the early days of marine insurance. Here, those wishing to undertake some risk would sign a documented agreement, hence becoming known as 'underwriters'.

Take the mortgage loan underwriter, for example. They review a property’s appraisal to confirm its accuracy – that the property is worth the purchase price and loan amount before approving or denying the loan. They give the final nod to all mortgage loans, with denied loans only being reconsidered if they present compelling evidence through an appeal process.

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, insurance underwriter jobs are projected to shrink by 4% between 2021 and 2031. These professionals analyze applications for coverage, granting or denying coverage based on their risk assessment.

In the equity markets, underwriters oversee the public distribution of securities – common or preferred stock – from a corporation or other issuing body. Particularly in the IPO process, underwriters set the initial offering price of the securities, purchase them from the issuer, and sell them to investors through their distribution network.

To accurately set the IPO price, underwriters connect with a broad network of investment groups, such as mutual funds and insurance companies, and their interest helps establish the stock's introductory price. Underwriters then ensure a specific number of shares is sold at the initial price and buy any surplus.

Underwriters also purchase and sell debt securities like government, corporate, municipal bonds or preferred stock, making a profit known as the underwriting spread. When multiple underwriters are needed for a debt security issuance, they form an underwriter syndicate.

In essence, underwriters are the financial experts assessing the viability of business risks. They bolster sales activities, perform key roles in mortgage approvals, insurance coverage, and contribute significantly to the equity market. These professionals can often be seen at the center of large, leveraged buyouts (LBOs), coordinating efforts while still performing their underwriting obligations, thus becoming a vital source of information regarding potential offerings or issues.

LEAD STORY